I’ve made no secret of not actually really wanting another child. I know I might (and very possibly will) change my mind, but for now the only thing that could tip the balance is feeling bad about LP growing up alone, which is a big thing, yes, but at the same time, not good enough of a reason for bringing another human being into this world.
Recently, I’ve heard about three different situations which all made me reflect on what pushes us to have children. I have a tendency to over-analyze everything, and deciding to become parents was a HUGE decision I really didn’t take lightly. I considered many, many things, including our financial situation, relationship stability, individual readiness, family health history, etc. And one of the reasons that make me not really desire a second child is probably due to this extreme carefulness I have (which I know is a bad trait, don’t get me wrong): I can’t see myself being capable of giving as much time and attention by splitting the same amount of it into two, and so it’s a bit of a deal-breaker for me. I know most people are different, though. They just go with the flow and make do, sometimes despite the sheer impractically or irrationality of it. But having kids should not have to do with being practical or rational, right? Or should it? This is the kind of issue I’m struggling with, because my impulse and my reason disagree; or rather never really talk to each other...
Here are the situations in question:
1: A mother to twin girls the same age as LP is suffering from a major, major bout with depression. It’s her third bout in less than a year. I know she was suffering from this disease before deciding to become pregnant, although I’m not sure to which extent.
2: A forty-something woman is undergoing painful and obstructive fertility treatments, and repeatedly miscarrying. She has three kids (10 to 17), from a first marriage, as well as a one year-old with her second husband. She desperately wants this fifth child.
3: A mother of two preschoolers really feels financially and mentally stretched, having a hard time supporting her family, which includes her aging mother who lives in their very cramped house. Yet, she decides to have a third kid.
It took me a long time to conceive, and I very much understand the depths of this desire that can wholly consume you: wanting to have a child. Still, all these situations bewilder me a little.
I’m feeling really sympathetic for the first woman, as debilitating depression must be terrible and is clearly not her fault (it could happen to anybody). Yet, I feel for the girls much more, since they will probably grow up scarred and, inevitably, a little s**ewed up from seeing their mom in this state of stupor most of the time, unable to fully engage with them. Not only the heredity factor is very strong, but the girls will also probably even think this is their fault, spending their childhood tiptoeing around the house to avoid making mommy upset… I don't know the complete history of this woman, and this is such a personal and emotional and touchy issue... Maybe her illness was never this severe before, but I'm just asking myself whether it is fair for someone who's been suffering from major depression most of her life to have kids (fair for them, I mean)? I'm not judging for I know she's still a great mother, but I think this is a question that can be legitimately asked... Am I insensitive for thinking that?
And again, you have to feel for someone who can’t conceive the child that she wants… Of course no one wishes repeated miscarriages to their worst enemy… But at the same time, it’s very common knowledge that this is the path you will likely follow if you try to conceive in your forties… Maternal age is, unfortunately, the most important factor in the fertility rate, and whether you like it or not, it’s always been that way. I know she probably had this dream of giving her new, younger husband the two kids he wanted, but I’ve always been very puzzled by these large blended families with huge age gaps (it figures, since I’ve never seen myself with a big family)… She’s having a really hard time coping with her seventeen year-old’s teenage angst and rebellion, she has two other pre-teens in the pipeline, AND a very young toddler… That's already a lot more than many women could chew! In this case, do you think she should keep trying and continue bearing this heavy burden on her shoulders to have this child at any cost, or just accept that it’s part of the aging process, that she’s done more than her part, and that maybe it’s time to close the factory, so to speak?
Finally, is it just me who thinks it's a tad irresponsible to bring a new child in a family that has insufficient space for him and who had trouble making ends meet even before he came, to a mom who already felt overwhelmed? Or is it just part of life, the way many people do around the world, and completely natural and normal?
I know my response to these situations may seem very intellectualized, even detached from the day-to-day reality of many families… I just don’t know, and I sometimes feel spending so much time in university wired my brain in a way that made me utterly incompetent at dealing with the simplest concrete matters (my first reaction is kinda like: “Does Kant has something to say about this?”, which tells you how much of a theory nerd/weirdo I am. Please don’t feel sorry for my son, I’m not neurotic like that all the time, just when I’m weighing a very important decision).
Providing you’re a reasonably responsible and well-meaning parent, should you take any of these factors (health, age, economical status, etc.) into consideration when deciding how many children you want, or should you just have an I-love-babies-so-let’s-have-another-one/if-there's-room-for-five-there's-room-for-six kind of attitude?
Should you adapt to what life throws at you, or should you stick to the number of kids you envisioned having when you were a teenager dreaming about the life you would have? And should you let your reason get in the way of your irrepressible desire for little ones?