Hello and welcome!

I live in Montreal, Quebec, and my first language is French.

May I insist on the fact that I love getting comments?

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Expectations vs reality

What could be reasonably expected from a 3 year-old during a two-week European vacation?

Bringing kids on trips seem fairly standard nowadays. Everyone around us is doing it, and even though we've done our fair share of traveling with LP starting when he was just 4 months old, we sometimes feel we're a little too cautious or too tame in doing this, being surrounded by people who go trekking for a month in Australia/South Africa/Patagonia with an infant, bring the kids to Japan for Christmas, you know what I mean. We always loved traveling and knew we wanted to bring our kids along -this is not a reproach to my parents who traveled quite a lot but never with us (with the exception of one time in Florida when I was five, and they had brought a nanny) because I know times were different and they had their reasons, but this is something that I truly wish had been different from my childhood.

The general assumption seems to be that you can take kids anywhere, and they will adjust to about any kind of conditions, providing they are reasonably safe. When we planned our trip, we pretty much thought about what we wanted to do and to see -the mountains for M, art and city browsing/shopping for me, etc. Italy is not Disney World; while it is quite kid-friendly in a way, it's just not in others, and there were days when LP was reeeally bored. He didn't care about the medieval sights or the wineries -for him, fun is playing in the park, or running in the grass, or seeing cars and machinery. When you ask him what he preferred, his anwser is very typically three-year-old-boy-ish: being at the airport, flying on the plane, taking the train, boating on the Mediterranean, taking the funicular up the Alps, AND especially visiting the Ferrari factory. Unsurprisingly, there is no mention of the Sistine chapel or the Coliseum in there.

Still, he did pretty well for the first part of the trip, the first ten days or so. He seemed to adapt to the absence of routine and change of schedule well, and there were only a few minor meltdowns -normal.

Then something happened: LP disappeared and was mostly replaced by a demon-child I really didn't like. There were a few days in Florence and Rome that were simply a disaster from morning to night: off-the-charts tantrums (I mean their intensity surprised even ourselves) to a scale we had never seen and where he was completely hysterical and out-of-control. We've talking craaaaazy screaming, kicking, punching my belly, being really aggressive and angry, displaying behaviors we had never seen him do before, like yelling at us to shut up, or the time he threw a small rock at me with all the strength in his little arms, narrowly missing my eye. After we were able to calm him down, there was a lot of explaining and reasoning and negotiation and sobbing and him feeling extremely sorry and shameful and telling us he would do better from now on... Until the whole circus started again an hour later. Really, walking all day in brutal heat was tough on all of us, especially for this pregnant chick, and we were at the end of our tether. Even while he's always been an intense and at times quite challenging child, never for a minute I had wanted to just turn my back and leave him somewhere before. But right then, I admit that sometimes for a second I really wanted to, for him to just not be my problem anymore.

In hindsight, there were a few things we could have done differently: not moving around so much, for instance, and rather settle in one or two bases. Two weeks was perhaps a bit long too, and 10 days may have been ideal. He didn't have much time or many places to blow some steam, and he went to bed late (even for our standards), usually around 10:00 or even 10:30 (we didn't have much control over this: dinners in restaurants were usually very long, and they're simply not open at 6 or so... Even when we showed up around 7:30, we were often the first patrons there).

And I mean, on top of all of this, he had every possible excuse in the book: the heat was sweltering, the days were long, and going from hotel to hotel, from restaurant to restaurant, always be looking for the next public restroom, and living off your suitcase can get hard on everyone. He's just 3! And has always thrived on his routine.

But then, there were other kids there, and they weren't acting out like this. We did see a few tantrumy-crying kids (let's not kid ourselves, vacations can be stressful to them), but never on that level, and in fact most were just being patient and nice and well-behaved. I know this partly has to do with temperament: even on a good day LP is very active and unwilling to stay into place for long, and so waiting for hours in his stroller during a guided tour was never going to happen, we were well aware of that. But this has left us exhausted and quite discouraged. And a bit lost. We do realize that some parents are simply handed easier kids than others, and that there's nothing you can do about that. But what are we supposed to do when this happens? Seeing him so unlike himself and so crazy, I couldn't help thinking where have we gone so wrong for him to behave this way? We were thinking that whatever we were doing wasn't helping much, and we were just so afraid that we had been turning him into a monster.

We've not been handling this really well. We had a hard time keeping our cool and not losing our patience, and we just weren't sure how to navigate through this. How can you make him feel that it's OK to be tired and bored and fed up, but that some gestures or attitudes or behaviors are simply unacceptable? And what are you supposed to do when you firmly say so, and give him very clear boundaries, but he just totally laughs them off and defiantly goes on? We never really had to face this, and it just doesn't come really naturally to us. Sadly, we both feel it's probably one of the most important things we just have to get right.

10 comment(s):

Natalie said...

We just got back too...but from Spain and BOY was it a different trip than what we are used to.

We faired out alot better with Felix than you seemed to have with LP....but I think our trips were pretty different. We 'considered' (briefly) doing the kind of trip you did, and quickly disregarded it, because we knew that we (including Felix) would not likely be able to handle its demands at this time.

What I think saved us during this trip were the following factors:

1 - We stayed put in one apartment the whole time.

2 - We did alot of groceries so when Felix started to show tell-tale signs of an upcoming meltdown...we stayed in.

3 - We only did one activity a day. It kinda sucked (for us) but it was the only way we could really guarantee that he'd make it through those long and hot days.

4 - We only went out to eat dinner late at night....on days when his afternoon nap was long enough for him to be able to handle staying out late. Again....it kinda sucked....actually, it sucked alot. We only ate dinner out about half of the time....BUT no meltdowns, or at least, only 1-2 on the entire trip.

It was still hard though....for so many reasons. It was hard because everything had to be thought out (i.e. what times does something open, when will he need to eat, is it too close to his naptime, etc...) so every activity took ALOT of planning (SO much more than we're used to)....but the trade-off (thankfully) was a pretty happy and well-behaved kid.

I look forward to doing a hotel/sightseeing trip with Felix....soon....but I think we still might be a couple of years away.

Natalie said...

PS - we also actively used bribery (mostly the pool at the apartment complex)...did you know that 2.5 year olds will do almost ANYTHING to go for a swim? Yea....neither did I!

Cate Subrosa said...

Aw, Marie-Eve, sounds like hard work. Especially pregnant. How has he been since you settled back into your routine at home?

Heather said...

Hi Marie-Ève!
It seems that you are able to pinpoint the triggers of L-P's meltdowns. As well, you wrote that he was well behaved for 10 days. I think that given his age, the lack of routine, the heat, etc., things went well.

Has he returned to his normal self now that you are home? If not, I think that it would be much easier to enforce boundaries at home than away from home.

I am not a mother, so perhaps I do not have the best advice. I am a teacher (elementary) so I have learned a few things about managins children. The lucky thing for me is that if I mess up one year, I get a fresh start the next. Hopefully my experience will pay off one day when I am a parent. For myself, if I remain calm and at least convince myself that I am in control, things will be better. If the consequence is clear and always enforced, things do get better. Although my perspective is different, I understand your frustration. I have lost many, many hours of sleep worry about such things.

THE ALTERNATIVE WIFE said...

Wow sorry that you had to experience that. But I have to say that I'm pretty amazed that he didn't loose it sooner. That sounds like a lot for me to take, never mind a 3 year old :)

Hope you're having a wonderful week, sweetie!

Rubiatonta said...

Sounds like you had your hands full at the end of your trip -- I'm sorry it was tough for you.

I think Natalie's got it right -- the trick is to make the travel experience as similar to the home experience as possible.

Kids from ages 2-5 are really routine-bound, and since this is the age when they are developing their own preferences, they react strongly, and sometimes inappropriately, to being asked to do what they do not prefer.

It's also important to remember that since their own environment and culture are still fairly new to them, they don't have the criteria to appreciate all of the differences and subtleties that an adult can. (Plus kids don't really crave "different" that much.)

A dear friend with two children has traveled with them from the time that they were small, but always based in a house or apartment somewhere, doing lots of day trips, and not overloading the schedule too much. She also made it a point, when they were quite little, to do things that they liked to do at home, too. Sometimes, the fact that you're going for a bike ride in another country is enough of a different experience for a little person.

Your resolve to get this right speaks volumes about you as a parent -- and remember that sometimes getting it "good enough" is plenty!

Adventures Along The Way said...

As someone who doesn't yet have a child, I don't have any insights but just wanted to say that I have been pondering this post since I read it yesterday. Parenting is such a challenging job and I respect parents (like you guys!) who are so intentional in how they raise their children. You guys are doing a great job with LP. And I also to say that perhaps it was just a weird combination of one-time events that set off some of these behaviors (adjusting to the idea of another kid coming to the family, travel exhaustion, boredom, the unfamiliar, heat, etc.).

I look forward to your continued reflections on raising kids. I feel like listening to other wise parents will help me (maybe one day) if I am a parent too and trying to figure it all out...

Bex said...

A very interesting post. We're going to Scotland in two weeks, but it won't be a sight-seeing trip as we're basically moving there for a few months. But after that we're hoping to do some traveling, and I've been pretty worried about how Jack will cope. I always seem to run into people who travel with their kids, and they have these "dream children" who take it all in a stride. But somehow I don't think that's Jack's style, so I'm apprehensive about what awaits us. I guess it is just a matter of doing it completely differently than we normally would.

Anyway, at least it sounds like you've established LP's limits. You know that he can do really well for 10 days--that's good news! You can plan your next vacation accordingly :)

Has he gone back to normal since you've gotten home?

Marie-Ève said...

Thanks everyone...

LP is doing better, and the reverting back to his routine seems to have done him good. The crazy tantrums did go on for over a week after we came back though, so we were worried (and exhausted). But I guess it's always the same with these tough phases -boundaries, consistency, and weathering them through. Other than that, they *will* pass.

Peonies and Polaroids said...

God, you guys did AMAZINGLY.

*I* can't handle travelling like you did and I'm 25. In fact there were times in New York when I was distinctly LP-ish. Ok, I stopped short of throwing stones at Nye's head but there was a lot of crying and foot stamping. I just need my home after three weeks. Moving around every few days would have made me absolutely intolerable.

I think that lasting as long as he did without starting to struggle is really impressive and it was your first try at a trip like this so you were just figuring things out.

And on how to handle super tantrums? I have no effing idea. I'll get back to you on that in 3-4 years. I think you're doing pretty bloody well.